Skip to main content
eBay Logo

Shop by category

Advanced
    • Daily Deals
    • Help & Contact
    • Loading...
      Error: Try Again
    • Sell
    • WatchlistExpand Watch List
      Loading...
      Sign in to see your user information
    • My eBayExpand My eBay
      • Summary
      • Recently Viewed
      • Bids/Offers
      • Watchlist
      • Purchase History
      • Buy Again
      • Selling
      • Saved Searches
      • Saved Sellers
      • Messages
    • Expand Cart
      Loading...
      Something went wrong. View cart for details.

    There seems to be a problem serving the request at this time

    You are here

    • eBay
    • Collectibles & Art
    • Collectibles
    • Non-Sport Trading Cards
    • Non-Sport Trading Card Singles
    • Cryptozoic Supernatural Collectable Trading Cards

    Cryptozoic Supernatural Collectable Trading Cards

    Side Refine Panel

    Shop by Category

    • Non-Sport Trading Cards
    • Trading Card Singles
    • Sealed Trading Card Packs
    • Sealed Trading Card Boxes
    • Sealed Trading Card Cases
    • Trading Card Lots
    • Trading Card Sets
    • Uncut Trading Card Sheets
    • Trading Card Box & Case Breaks
    • Non-Sport Trading Card NFTs
    • Wrappers & Empty Card Boxes
    • Non-Sport Card Supplies & Accessories
    • Price Guides & Publications
    • Other Non-Sport Trading Card Merchandise

    Shop by Genre

    • Sci-Fi

      Sci-Fi

    • TV & Movies

      TV & Movies

    • Fantasy

      Fantasy

    • All

    • Auction

    • Buy It Now

    • Best Match
    • Time: ending soonest
    • Time: newly listed
    • Price + Shipping: lowest first
    • Price + Shipping: highest first
    • Distance: nearest first
    • List View

    176 Results

      • Franchise: Supernatural filter applied
      • Manufacturer: Cryptozoic filter applied
      Clear All
      • Supernatural filter applied
      • Cryptozoic filter applied
      • All Listings filter applied
    • Supernatural Season 4-6 Jared Padalecki Sam Winchester Wardrobe Card M12
      SPONSORED

      Supernatural Season 4-6 Jared Padalecki Sam Winchester Wardrobe Card M12

      ILS 199.12
      Was: ILS 209.60
      ILS 102.06 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Supernatural Seasons 4 - 6 Jensen Ackles as Dean M03 Wardrobe Card PSA (MGC)
      SPONSORED

      Supernatural Seasons 4 - 6 Jensen Ackles as Dean M03 Wardrobe Card PSA (MGC)

      ILS 742.37
      ILS 70.84 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Supernatural Seasons 4-6 Autograph Card EP Emily Perkins as Becky Rosen
      SPONSORED

      Supernatural Seasons 4-6 Autograph Card EP Emily Perkins as Becky Rosen

      ILS 117.18
      ILS 67.36 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Supernatural Seasons 4-6 Autograph Card MS Mark Sheppard As Crowley PSA MGC 9
      SPONSORED

      Supernatural Seasons 4-6 Autograph Card MS Mark Sheppard As Crowley PSA MGC 9

      ILS 644.53
      ILS 68.61 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • SUPERNATURAL SEASONS 4 - 6: CHASE CARD SET: LOCATIONS SET - ALL 9 CARDS

      SUPERNATURAL SEASONS 4 - 6: CHASE CARD SET: LOCATIONS SET - ALL 9 CARDS

      ILS 23.44
      ILS 16.41 shipping
      or Best Offer
      2 watching
    • Cryptozoic Supernatural Season 4-6 Kurt Fuller Autograph #KF - QTY AVAIL

      Cryptozoic Supernatural Season 4-6 Kurt Fuller Autograph #KF - QTY AVAIL

      ILS 96.71
      ILS 85.16 shipping
      or Best Offer
      8 watching
    • SUPERNATURAL SEASONS 1 - 3: CHASE CARD SET: LOCATIONS SET - ALL 9 CARDS

      SUPERNATURAL SEASONS 1 - 3: CHASE CARD SET: LOCATIONS SET - ALL 9 CARDS

      ILS 78.15
      ILS 16.41 shipping
      or Best Offer
      3 watching
    • Cryptozoic Supernatural Season 4-6 Christopher Heyerdahl Autograph #CH - QTY

      Cryptozoic Supernatural Season 4-6 Christopher Heyerdahl Autograph #CH - QTY

      ILS 145.07
      ILS 87.29 shipping
      or Best Offer
      Only 1 left!
    • 2016 Supernatural Seasons 4-6: Join the Hunt Disguises Back to School Sorta 9aj

      2016 Supernatural Seasons 4-6: Join the Hunt Disguises Back to School Sorta 9aj

      ILS 20.09
      ILS 97.93 shipping
    • Supernatural Seasons 1-3 2014 Character Bios Shadowbox Chase Set CP1 to CP9

      Supernatural Seasons 1-3 2014 Character Bios Shadowbox Chase Set CP1 to CP9

      ILS 449.31
      ILS 42.94 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Supernatural Seasons 4-6 Dual Wardrobe Card DM2 Misha Collins And Julie McNiven

      Supernatural Seasons 4-6 Dual Wardrobe Card DM2 Misha Collins And Julie McNiven

      ILS 725.50
      ILS 101.09 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Supernatural Seasons 1-3 2014 Costume Wardrobe Relic Card M10 John Winchester

      Supernatural Seasons 1-3 2014 Costume Wardrobe Relic Card M10 John Winchester

      ILS 273.48
      ILS 42.94 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Supernatural Seasons 1-3 Winchester Brothers Mega Moon Lava Parallel Set J1-J9

      Supernatural Seasons 1-3 Winchester Brothers Mega Moon Lava Parallel Set J1-J9

      ILS 332.09
      ILS 46.85 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Supernatural Seasons 1-3 2014 Costume Wardrobe Relic Card M11 Sam Winchester
      SPONSORED

      Supernatural Seasons 1-3 2014 Costume Wardrobe Relic Card M11 Sam Winchester

      ILS 390.70
      ILS 46.85 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Supernatural Seasons 1-3 2014 Costume Wardrobe Relic Card M13 Sam Winchester
      SPONSORED

      Supernatural Seasons 1-3 2014 Costume Wardrobe Relic Card M13 Sam Winchester

      ILS 390.70
      ILS 46.85 shipping
      or Best Offer
      2 watching
    • Supernatural Seasons 1-3 2014 Costume Wardrobe Relic Card M08 Sam Winchester
      SPONSORED

      Supernatural Seasons 1-3 2014 Costume Wardrobe Relic Card M08 Sam Winchester

      ILS 390.70
      ILS 46.85 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • 2014 SUPERNATURAL CRYPTOZOIC SEASONS 1-3 FAITH #14 GOLD SSP /10 PSA 9 MINT DEAN!

      2014 SUPERNATURAL CRYPTOZOIC SEASONS 1-3 FAITH #14 GOLD SSP /10 PSA 9 MINT DEAN!

      ILS 806.12
      ILS 87.64 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Supernatural Seasons 1-3 2014 Costume Wardrobe Relic Card M05 Sam Winchester

      Supernatural Seasons 1-3 2014 Costume Wardrobe Relic Card M05 Sam Winchester

      ILS 293.02
      ILS 46.85 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Cryptozoic Supernatural Season 4-6 Julia Maxwell Autograph #JM - QTY AVAIL

      Cryptozoic Supernatural Season 4-6 Julia Maxwell Autograph #JM - QTY AVAIL

      ILS 128.95
      ILS 86.58 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Supernatural Seasons 4-6 Magenta Printing Plate 1/1 Card #42 Saying No

      Supernatural Seasons 4-6 Magenta Printing Plate 1/1 Card #42 Saying No

      ILS 390.70
      ILS 42.94 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Supernatural Seasons 1-3 2014 Costume Wardrobe Relic Card M14 Sam Winchester

      Supernatural Seasons 1-3 2014 Costume Wardrobe Relic Card M14 Sam Winchester

      ILS 390.70
      ILS 46.85 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Cryptozoic Supernatural Season 4-6 Nicholas Elia Autograph #NE - QTY AVAIL

      Cryptozoic Supernatural Season 4-6 Nicholas Elia Autograph #NE - QTY AVAIL

      ILS 58.01
      ILS 83.48 shipping
      Only 1 left!
    • Supernatural Seasons 1-3 Wardrobe Card M07 Rob Benedict as Chuck Shurley

      Supernatural Seasons 1-3 Wardrobe Card M07 Rob Benedict as Chuck Shurley

      ILS 136.72
      ILS 46.85 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Supernatural Seasons 1-3 2014 Costume Wardrobe Relic Card M21 Dean Winchester

      Supernatural Seasons 1-3 2014 Costume Wardrobe Relic Card M21 Dean Winchester

      ILS 586.07
      ILS 46.85 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Supernatural Seasons 1-3 Dean Winchester M21 Binder Exclusive - Cryptozoic 2014

      Supernatural Seasons 1-3 Dean Winchester M21 Binder Exclusive - Cryptozoic 2014

      ILS 419.17
      ILS 109.02 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Supernatural Seasons 1-3 2014 Costume Wardrobe Relic Card M20 Harry Spangler

      Supernatural Seasons 1-3 2014 Costume Wardrobe Relic Card M20 Harry Spangler

      ILS 273.48
      ILS 46.85 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Supernatural Seasons 1-3 Wardrobe Card M13 Julia Maxwell as Eve

      Supernatural Seasons 1-3 Wardrobe Card M13 Julia Maxwell as Eve

      ILS 179.70
      ILS 46.85 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Supernatural Seasons 1-3 Join The Hunt: Costume Card (M02) Sam Winchester

      Supernatural Seasons 1-3 Join The Hunt: Costume Card (M02) Sam Winchester

      ILS 187.52
      ILS 23.44 shipping
      10 watching
    • Supernatural Seasons 4-6 Autograph Card JH Jessica Heafey as Gwen Campbell
      SPONSORED

      Supernatural Seasons 4-6 Autograph Card JH Jessica Heafey as Gwen Campbell

      ILS 113.12
      ILS 67.13 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Supernatural Join the Hunt Seasons 1 - 3 Autograph Card A20 Eric Kripke Creator
      SPONSORED

      Supernatural Join the Hunt Seasons 1 - 3 Autograph Card A20 Eric Kripke Creator

      ILS 390.70
      ILS 62.83 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Supernatural Seasons 1-3 Dual Wardrobe Card DM2 Misha Collins & Julie McNiven
      SPONSORED

      Supernatural Seasons 1-3 Dual Wardrobe Card DM2 Misha Collins & Julie McNiven

      ILS 586.07
      ILS 46.85 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Supernatural Seasons 4-6 Trading Cards: Demore Barnes Autograph Card DB Raphael
      SPONSORED

      Supernatural Seasons 4-6 Trading Cards: Demore Barnes Autograph Card DB Raphael

      ILS 97.49
      ILS 66.23 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Supernatural Seasons 1-3 Wardrobe Card M06 Meg Masters

      Supernatural Seasons 1-3 Wardrobe Card M06 Meg Masters

      ILS 63.11
      ILS 99.03 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Cryptozoic Supernatural Season 4-6 Jessica Heafy Autograph #JH - QTY AVAIL

      Cryptozoic Supernatural Season 4-6 Jessica Heafy Autograph #JH - QTY AVAIL

      ILS 161.20
      ILS 87.97 shipping
      or Best Offer
      5 watching
    • Supernatural Join The Hunt Seasons 4-6: Rick Worthy Variant R W.

      Supernatural Join The Hunt Seasons 4-6: Rick Worthy Variant R W.

      ILS 95.73
      ILS 23.44 shipping
      12 watching
    • Supernatural Seasons 4-6 Dual Wardrobe Card DM1 Jared Padalcki & Jensen Ackles

      Supernatural Seasons 4-6 Dual Wardrobe Card DM1 Jared Padalcki & Jensen Ackles

      ILS 725.50
      ILS 101.09 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Cryptozoic Supernatural Season 4-6 Katherine Boecher Autograph #KB - QTY AVAIL

      Cryptozoic Supernatural Season 4-6 Katherine Boecher Autograph #KB - QTY AVAIL

      ILS 209.57
      ILS 90.10 shipping
      or Best Offer
      9 watching
    • Supernatural Seasons 1-3 Dual Wardrobe Card DM3 Chuck Shurley and Becky Rosen

      Supernatural Seasons 1-3 Dual Wardrobe Card DM3 Chuck Shurley and Becky Rosen

      ILS 410.24
      ILS 46.85 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Supernatural Seasons 1-3 Wardrobe Card M09 Rick Worthy as Alpha Vampire VARIANT
      SPONSORED

      Supernatural Seasons 1-3 Wardrobe Card M09 Rick Worthy as Alpha Vampire VARIANT

      ILS 269.57
      ILS 46.85 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Supernatural Seasons 1-3 Wardrobe Card HT5 Misha Collins & Jared Padalecki
      SPONSORED

      Supernatural Seasons 1-3 Wardrobe Card HT5 Misha Collins & Jared Padalecki

      ILS 683.76
      ILS 46.85 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Supernatural Join the hunt seasons 1-3: John Winchester's Wardrobe card M 10.

      Supernatural Join the hunt seasons 1-3: John Winchester's Wardrobe card M 10.

      ILS 136.56
      ILS 23.44 shipping
    • SUPERNATURAL CRYPTOZOIC SEASONS 1-3 #58 "GORDON'S FATE" SILVER FOIL VARIANT /25

      SUPERNATURAL CRYPTOZOIC SEASONS 1-3 #58 "GORDON'S FATE" SILVER FOIL VARIANT /25

      ILS 161.20
      ILS 102.48 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Supernatural Seasons 4-6 Autograph Card AG Amy Gumenick As Young Mary Winchester

      Supernatural Seasons 4-6 Autograph Card AG Amy Gumenick As Young Mary Winchester

      ILS 483.66
      ILS 95.38 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • SUPERNATURAL CRYPTOZOIC SEASONS 1-3 #32 SILVER FOIL VARIANT /25 DEAN RARE!

      SUPERNATURAL CRYPTOZOIC SEASONS 1-3 #32 SILVER FOIL VARIANT /25 DEAN RARE!

      ILS 161.20
      ILS 102.48 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • SUPERNATURAL CRYPTOZOIC SEASONS 4-6 CHARACTER BIOS RUBY II C6 INSERT

      SUPERNATURAL CRYPTOZOIC SEASONS 4-6 CHARACTER BIOS RUBY II C6 INSERT

      ILS 19.32
      ILS 81.81 shipping
    • Supernatural Seasons 4-6 Black Printing Plate 1/1 Card #68 Let It Bleed

      Supernatural Seasons 4-6 Black Printing Plate 1/1 Card #68 Let It Bleed

      ILS 390.70
      ILS 46.85 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • SUPERNATURAL CRYPTOZOIC SEASONS 4-6 ZACHARIAH FOIL CHARACTER BIOS INSERT C5 SP

      SUPERNATURAL CRYPTOZOIC SEASONS 4-6 ZACHARIAH FOIL CHARACTER BIOS INSERT C5 SP

      ILS 25.76
      ILS 82.10 shipping
    • SUPERNATURAL SEASONS 1 - 3: CHASE CARD SET: WINCHESTER BROTHERS SET ALL 9 CARDS

      SUPERNATURAL SEASONS 1 - 3: CHASE CARD SET: WINCHESTER BROTHERS SET ALL 9 CARDS

      ILS 78.15
      ILS 16.41 shipping
      or Best Offer

    Results Pagination - Page 1

    1. 1
    2. 2
    3. 3
    4. 4

    Additional site navigation

    • About eBay
    • Announcements
    • Community
    • Security Center
    • Seller Information Center
    • Policies
    • Affiliates
    • Help & Contact
    • Site Map
    Copyright © 1995-2022 eBay Inc. All Rights Reserved. User Agreement, Privacy, Cookies and AdChoice